GCR

We recently interviewed Arthur Breitman Diego Olivier Fernandez Pons on Tezos Communities. Below is the transcript:

This is our newly released podcast in partnership with Tezos.

Joyce Yang

Welcome to Tezos in Asia, a series featuring and showcasing the growing Tezos communities in Asia. I’m your host, Joyce Yang, founder of Global Coin Research. follow me in my journey in exploring and meeting the various Tezos communities in Korea, Japan, Southeast Asia, China and more. Learn about the crypto happenings in each of these countries, the cultural backdrop and regulatory frameworks, and what these communities are doing locally.

In this very first episode, I’m in Seoul, Korea, attending a Tezos Korea conference, and learning about the background and the history of these Tezos communities from two involved members. I speak to Arthur Breitman, founder of Tezos, and Diego Olivier Fernandez Pons, a former Tezos foundation board member and currently the scientific advisor of Tezos Southeast Asia.

In this first conversation, I speak with Arthur about the importance of a having global presence for Tezos and I ask him for some of his thoughts on the communities. But before that, we had Arthur just give a quick introduction of himself as well as Tezos and the community.

Arthur Breitman

My name is Arthur, and my background, I studied math and physics. I worked in finance for a long time. I was aquant, working in high-frequency trading, I then worked a little bit in robotics, I was working at Waymo, which is Google’s self-driving car, or Alphabet I should say, self-driving cars division. So that was a nice change before really just jumping full time on Tezos.

On the project itself, so Tezos is a cryptocurrency, and it’s a smart contract platform. Originally, the problem it really tries to address is a question of governance in cryptocurrencies, and sometimes people will say like oh, it adds governance, but it doesn’t add governance. Every project has governance. It can be explicit, but it’s always there. There’s always a form of governance.

And the idea was, instead of trying to have rough consensus and implicit governance, which I think can devolve into handing out a lot of power to a few people, the idea was to have explicit governance starting with a simple mechanism on-chain based voting, and then progressively improving the governance and improving the methods by which the protocol evolves. And that’s I think you can strike a good balance between being agile and being able to evolve and make changes and between having security and stability. So that was originally embedded in this project

Joyce Yang

And how do you see these communities evolve?

Arthur Breitman

By their nature, blockchains are pretty global, I think that’s what makes them interesting is that they’re borderless, and that’s valuable. However, I think that from a human perspective, we’re still local creatures. We interact with people around us in our local communities. And so I would say that having this local chapters of the projects, local places where people can meet and discuss, I think is very important in order to foster adoption, education, and understanding of the of the project.

Joyce Yang

And as a reminder for our listeners. We are here in Seoul, Korea for the Tezos conference organized by Tezos Korea.

Yeah, we’re here in Korea and the event has a great turnout and great energy, and people are asking questions about very technical things that you’re speaking about.

What do you think of the communities here?

Arthur Breitman

I’ve had so far two trips to Korea and two trips to Japan so I’m speaking from limited experience, but everyone I’ve met has been great and I really enjoyed the communities that I’ve met and the members that I’ve met in those places. And what I like is the self-organization has been really like they are now foundations in many different countries in Asia and that’s really exciting. Like taking the matters into their own hands and moving things forward, so I think that’s pretty impressive to see.

Joyce Yang

What’s your general observation of the Korean community versus the rest of the communities that you have seen and visited?

Arthur Breitman

What I noticed is that the materials which have been produced by the Tezos Korea community have been very high-quality. I think the events are always very well organized. The infographics that came out of Korea have also been superb.

So I also see that something, which is new now that wasn’t there last time was [them] trying to have more partnerships with universities, for research. So it’s a burgeoning ecosystem.

Joyce Yang

What’s your vision for these communities?

Arthur Breitman

I mean, what matters is their vision, not my vision, But…

Joyce Yang

How do you support that vision and how do you envision the foundation continue to support that vision?

Arthur Breitman

At the end of the day, you know one thing I really like is meetups. When I moved to New York, about 14 years ago, I didn’t know many people and I went to these meetups and what I found great about meetups is that you could find meetups on any topic you wanted. And that was really cool and for example, you could go to a machine learning meetup or you go to a science meetup and I created one myself. I had like a libertarian meetup for example.

And in some sense, what I hope to see in the future is that you basically have these meetup groups for Tezos or just different community groups for Tezos and there’s no rule in what they have. There’s no rule in what they have to be. It’s just a lot of people who are interested in it and wanted to discuss this and there would be I guess a mix of people who are using it, people who are building applications on it, people who are doing research around it, people who want to change the protocol. All of this interest kind of like spread out across the world and loosely coupled.

Joyce Yang

Yeah. And do you see the Asian communities making up a large percentage of the participants of these communities?

Arthur Breitman

I mean that’s a large percentage of the world, so yes.

Joyce Yang

Yes, that’s great. I think that’s a very much untapped market. A lot of projects haven’t been really pay attention to, or think about in a way that you guys have been thinking about it.

Arthur Breitman

I get the sense that maybe some projects… a lot of projects seems to be local. They start in one region and then the participants only focus on that region as opposed to looking across the world and so I get a feeling sometimes that maybe some people in Europe are going to look at European projects and then people in Asia are going to get Asian projects, but there’s no reason. It doesn’t have to be this way.

Joyce Yang

I agree. And do you have any advice for even project leaders and CEOs who need to think about their projects globally?

Arthur Breitman

One thing I think about often is there was a social network Orchid that was launched by Google and it was randomly huge in Brazil. Who knows? why Brazil? And I don’t know exactly why it was huge in Brazil, but it could just be randomly that…

Joyce Yang

They found product market…

Arthur Breitman

They have product-market fit, a lot of people were there, and all of a sudden, all of Brazil are on Orchid and there you go, you have a social network. And I’ve always said that you never know, maybe you create something and you don’t know necessarily where it’s going to stick or who your best audience is going to be, and being in many jurisdictions and many countries I think is a good approach towards that. And I guess one advice I would give is you know don’t ever look at any locale… you don’t know where your users are necessarily going to be.

In that respect, I think that we could be doing a little better with localization of documents. I think it’s important to be available in many languages. I know that there’s a translation effort that Tezos Korea does and Tezos Japan does.I often see materials in Korea or Japan on the web and Japanese on the web. So that’s great. I’m also biased because of the media that I read, like I read Twitter, but I’m not a fan of Telegram so I’m probably missing out on all the Russian, I’m not on Kakao.

Yeah, it’s tough. I think the answer to that is decentralization. I don’t know enough about Korea, but the people in Korea knows about Korea. So I think it’s great if they are empowered to make decisions locally.

Joyce Yang

Next, I speak with Diego and learn about the various Tezos communities and how they are set up locally. Diego was a former Tezos foundation board member and currently the scientific advisor of Tezos Southeast Asia. Let’s hear what he says about the Tezos communities and how they are set up.

Diego Olivier Fernandez Pons

So there are Tezos communities all around the world. And these communities had already organized by themselves before even getting any kind of support from the Tezos foundation. They were organized in the form of meetups, in the form of small events, very often forums and things like that. And out of all those organizations, there are a couple of them that decided to move one step more, one step higher in the legal form in such a way that they can be supported with funds from the Tezos Foundation.

When the Tezos foundation sends funds to any organization, they expect to have an organization in front that needs to have accounting, that needs to have auditing, that needs to have a legal organization. They cannot just send money to 5 guys sitting in a bar. So out of all the spontaneous organizations and former organization around the world, there are 5 that made the effort of creating a legal entity to support them. And those are Tezos Commons foundation in the United States; and here in Asia in order of appearance, that is Tezos Korea, was the first one to organize itself. After that it was probably Tezos Japan, Tezos Southeast Asia and the last one is Tezos Hong Kong-China.

And now all these organizations have a legal framework in which they operate. Most of them tend to organize as foundations, which means that they have their own board members that are all local, that they have team whose job is to organize events that can be events for the community, that can be research and development related events, partnership with universities, training and all types of events. And so those are the big 5 communities that are organized and many smaller organizations around the world. There are a couple of associations, and there are also a lot of informal organizations. So many that actually, I don’t know them all.

Joyce Yang

How have you seen the communities evolved in the last year? I think now the communities are getting solidified, there are more events in these local regions.

Diego Olivier Fernandez Pons

What I think is remarkable is that the communities have developed themselves locally in the sense that Tezos Korea is an organization that is truly Korean. They decided to work with their local universities, so they passed agreements with the local universities, they convinced industrials, they convinced lawmakers, they convinced different figures to join Korean figures to join this current community.

That is very good because it gives the local support that local users need, in the sense that when you’re a local company and you want to use Tezos, you will feel much more confident if you have in front of you people that speak the same language, that are that have the same cultural background, that know how business is done in Korea, that work with local universities that will be able to train engineers that you can hire.

Immediately, that’s industrial environment that is much more robust and much more comfortable than being and working with companies that are all around the world, where you have to work with American engineers because that’s the only ones that they have, and you have to send them from overseas here and those sort of things.

So it’s really much better for local industries to have a local community, and all the local communities have developed themselves locally. Same thing for Southeast Asia that has a board of Singaporean members, and I think for Japan, that works with local Japanese technical people, marketing board members, industrials, etc. etc. etc. So that allows the Tezos ecosystem to develop first organically and also to have a better development because they know better what is the best for their industry, their country and the way of managing all that. So that’s very good.

Joyce Yang

Yeah. Is there anything particularly about the Korean community, that you find very unique what these guys are doing here versus the other communities, since we’re here in Korea?

Diego Olivier Fernandez Pons

So each community has, because of its leaders and because of the type of network that they have, a has a different orientation. Tezos Korea is very good at the events. The events are very high quality, everybody is impressed by the events that they make, and the visibility that they achieve with those events. Tezos Japan is very industrial in the sense that they have contracts with a lot of industry groups which is very surprising to see how much traction they have in the industry.

Ending

Want to hear more? In the following episodes, we’ll be speaking to Tezos Korea and a number of other communities. We’ll go into detail about what’s going on in these local communities and how each of them is organized.

To learn more about Tezos and the Tezos communities, make sure to check out the website links listed below and follow Tezos. This podcast is produced by Global Coin Research.

Episode links:

Arthur Breitman, co-founder of Tezos: Twitter

Diego Olivier Fernandez Pons, former board member of the Tezos foundation: Linkedin

Tezos Korea Foundation: http://tezoskorea.foundation

Tezos Korea Conference: http://tezoskorea.foundation/talk/